Explainers / Injury

California comparative fault after an accident

California does not bar an injury claim just because the injured person was partly at fault. The state uses pure comparative fault. A jury, or an insurer in a negotiation, assigns percentages. The injured person’s recovery is reduced by that person’s percentage. Someone found 20 percent at fault can still recover 80 percent of the damages. Someone found 70 percent at fault can still recover 30 percent. There is no cutoff at 50 percent, which is the rule in some other states.

Where the rule comes from

Civil Code section 1714 states the basic California rule: everyone is responsible for injuries caused by a want of ordinary care, except so far as the injured person was willfully or negligently responsible. For many years courts used contributory negligence, which could wipe out a claim if the injured person was at fault at all. In 1975 the California Supreme Court rejected that approach in Li v. Yellow Cab Co., 13 Cal.3d 804. The court adopted comparative negligence so that liability is apportioned in proportion to fault. Later cases extended the same idea of comparing fault to some strict-liability settings and to apportionment among defendants. The label “pure” means the plaintiff’s share, however large, reduces damages instead of closing the courthouse door.

What gets compared

Fault is not only the moment of impact. A driver who speeds, a driver who turns left without yielding, a property owner who leaves a spill, and a person who walks while looking at a phone can all be assigned shares if the evidence supports it. The question is whether each person’s conduct was a substantial factor in causing the harm, and how the responsibility should be divided. The fact that one person broke a traffic law is evidence of negligence. It is not always 100 percent of the fault. The fact that the other person also broke a rule can move the percentages.

Seat-belt use is a common argument in car cases. California allows a defendant, in a proper case, to argue that failure to wear a belt increased the injuries. That argument is about the damages caused by the failure, not an automatic loss of the whole claim. Proposition 213, codified in Civil Code sections 3333.3 and 3333.4, limits the kinds of damages an uninsured driver, or a person injured while committing a felony, can recover. Those limits are specific statutes. They are not the same thing as comparative fault, and they should not be mixed together in a casual conversation.

Several defendants

When more than one person is at fault, California generally compares all of them, including people who are not in the lawsuit, for purposes of allocating noneconomic damages in many negligence cases. Proposition 51, Civil Code section 1431.2, makes defendants severally liable, not jointly liable, for noneconomic damages such as pain. Economic damages, such as medical bills and lost wages, can still be joint and several in many negligence cases, meaning one defendant may have to pay the full economic loss and then seek contribution. The practical effect is that a 10 percent defendant might still be asked to pay a larger share of the medical bills if the main defendant has no insurance. Apportionment is one reason the available insurance matters as much as the percentage on a chart.

How insurers use the rule

Before anyone files a lawsuit, insurers trade percentages. An offer that “accepts 50 percent” is a negotiation position. It is not a court finding. Recorded statements, photographs, vehicle damage, and witness accounts are how those percentages get built. A person who says “it was all my fault” at the scene, before seeing the other driver’s speed or the signal, hands the insurer a sentence that is hard to walk back. Describing what you saw is safer than announcing a legal conclusion.

Comparative fault also affects settlement value in a dog-bite or premises case. Civil Code section 3342 can make a dog owner responsible for a bite even without prior knowledge of a vicious dog. The injured person’s own conduct, such as provoking the dog, can still reduce the amount. Strict liability and comparative fault are not opposites in California practice. One can create responsibility. The other can divide it.

What the rule does not do

Comparative fault does not extend a statute of limitations. A person who is only 10 percent at fault still has to file on time. It does not create insurance that does not exist. It does not apply, in the same way, to every contract dispute or to a workers’ compensation claim, which is mostly a no-fault system against the employer. It does not require a jury. Most claims resolve by agreement, and the percentages are part of the bargaining.

If you are deciding whether to accept an offer, ask what percentage of fault the offer assumes and what damages it leaves out. A low percentage of a complete set of damages can be worth more than a high percentage of an incomplete medical picture. This article describes the rule. It does not assign a percentage to any crash.

This is general information about California law, not legal advice. Deadlines and exceptions depend on the facts. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Find an attorney