Explainers / Injury

California premises liability

Premises liability is the claim that a property owner, tenant, or manager failed to use reasonable care and someone was hurt. A wet floor, a broken step, poor lighting, a falling object, or a known criminal hazard can all be the setting. The name of the claim does not matter as much as the duty and the proof. A fall, by itself, does not prove the claim.

The duty of ordinary care

Civil Code section 1714 is the starting point. Everyone is responsible for an injury occasioned by a want of ordinary care in the management of their property or person, except so far as the injured person was responsible. California does not sort visitors into rigid categories of invitee, licensee, and trespasser the way some states still do. The California Supreme Court explained in Rowland v. Christian, 69 Cal.2d 108 (1968), that the basic measure is reasonable care under all the circumstances, with the injured person’s status one factor among others rather than a complete bar. Later statutes restored some limits, especially for people who enter property to commit a crime and for certain recreational uses. The general rule for a customer in a store or a guest in an apartment remains ordinary care.

Ordinary care means what a reasonable owner would do: fix a hazard, guard it, or warn of it, depending on the risk and on what the owner knew or should have known. An owner is not an insurer of every visitor’s safety. A freshly spilled drink that no employee had a chance to see is a different case from a spill that sat in a grocery aisle for an hour. Notice, actual or constructive, is often the fight. Constructive notice means the hazard existed long enough that a careful owner would have found it. The length of time, the inspection schedule, and video of the area are how that question is answered.

Who can be responsible

The owner, the commercial tenant, and a maintenance company can each have a share if each had a duty over the condition. A lease sometimes shifts repair duties. The lease does not bind the injured person, who was not a party to it, but it helps show who was supposed to act. A store is generally responsible for the aisles it controls during business hours. A landlord of an apartment building is generally responsible for common stairs and for defects in the building the landlord is obligated to repair. A tenant can be responsible for a hazard the tenant created inside the rented unit.

Criminal attacks on property are sometimes framed as premises cases when the owner had notice of similar crimes and failed to take reasonable security measures. Those cases are harder than a broken step. Prior incidents, lighting, locks, and the foreseeability of the attack are the evidence. The mere fact that a crime occurred does not make the owner responsible.

The injured person’s own care

Comparative fault applies. A person who walked into an obvious hazard while looking at a phone, or who ignored a cone and a warning sign, can have the recovery reduced. An open and obvious condition is relevant to whether the owner acted reasonably and to the visitor’s own care. It is not an automatic defense in every California case. A warning that is inadequate, or a hazard that cannot be avoided, can still support a claim.

Children and people with disabilities are part of “all the circumstances.” A step that is reasonable for an empty warehouse may be unreasonable at the entrance of a clinic. The standard stays reasonable care. It does not become a guarantee.

Government property

Sidewalks, courthouse steps, and public transit platforms are often controlled by a city, county, or the state. A lawsuit against that entity generally requires a written government claim within six months under Government Code section 911.2. Government Code section 830 and the sections around it also set public-entity rules about dangerous conditions of public property, including what counts as a dangerous condition and what immunities may apply. Those rules are more specific than section 1714. A private-store analysis does not copy over to a city sidewalk without change.

Deadlines and records

An injury lawsuit against a private owner is generally due within two years under Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1. Photograph the condition before it is cleaned up, if you can do that safely. Get names of employees who were present. Ask the business to preserve video, in writing, because many systems overwrite within days. Medical records connect the fall to the injury. Without that link, a dangerous condition is only a maintenance issue.

Incident reports filled out for the business are useful and also one-sided. Read what you sign. A sentence that says the fall was entirely your fault is the comparative-fault problem described above, written in your own hand.

This article states the duty. It does not find that any store, landlord, or city failed to meet it.

This is general information about California law, not legal advice. Deadlines and exceptions depend on the facts. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Find an attorney