Explainers / Injury

Uber and Lyft accidents in California

A crash involving a rideshare vehicle is still a negligence case. Someone failed to use ordinary care, and someone was hurt. The insurance is what makes these cases look different. California regulates transportation network companies, the legal name for Uber, Lyft, and similar platforms, through the Public Utilities Commission and the Public Utilities Code. The insurance that has to be in place depends on what the driver and the app were doing at the moment of the crash.

The three periods

The CPUC and Public Utilities Code section 5433 describe three periods.

Period 1 is when the driver has the app on and is waiting for a ride request. The required primary coverage is at least $50,000 for death and injury per person, $100,000 per incident, and $30,000 for property damage. There is also an excess requirement of at least $200,000 per occurrence. Coverage can be carried by the driver, by the company, or by a combination, if it actually covers TNC use.

Period 2 is when a ride has been accepted and the driver is on the way to pick up the passenger. Period 3 is when the passenger is in the vehicle until the passenger gets out. In periods 2 and 3, the required primary commercial coverage is $1 million. In period 3, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage of $60,000 per person and $300,000 per incident is also required. Those figures are statutory minimums, not a statement of what any one policy will pay for a particular injury, and not a cap on what a negligent driver might owe.

The personal auto policy on the driver’s car often excludes paid rideshare use. Public Utilities Code section 5432 requires the company to disclose to drivers that a personal policy may not cover TNC driving, including collision damage to the driver’s own car from the moment the driver logs on until the driver logs off. A driver who assumes “my own insurance will handle it” can be wrong the moment the app is open.

Passengers, other drivers, and people on foot

A passenger hurt in period 3 is usually looking at the $1 million commercial policy and at the liability of whoever caused the crash. That might be the rideshare driver, another motorist, or both under comparative fault. A passenger is not automatically at fault for sitting in the back seat. A passenger who grabbed the wheel or opened a door into traffic can have a share of fault.

Another driver or a pedestrian hit by a rideshare car has a claim against the at-fault driver and, depending on the period, against the TNC policy. Identifying the period is essential. A screenshot of the app, a receipt for the trip, and the time of the crash are the documents that sort period 1 from period 3. Ask the company, in writing, to preserve trip data. Electronic records are easier to get early than months later.

Drivers hurt in a crash raise a second system. If the driver is an employee, workers’ compensation may apply. California has treated the employment status of rideshare drivers as a contested legal question tied to Assembly Bill 5, Proposition 22, and court decisions interpreting them. This article does not resolve whether a particular driver is an employee. A driver who was injured should ask both about the TNC insurance period and about whether a job-injury claim exists. Missing one system because you assumed the other would pay is a common and expensive mistake.

The underlying injury rules do not change

Comparative fault, the two-year lawsuit period in Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1, and the six-month government-claim rule if a public entity is involved all still apply. Medical care, photographs, and a cautious approach to recorded statements matter here as they do in any crash. An early offer from one of several insurers may not account for which policy is primary.

Uninsured motorist issues are sharper in period 3 because the statute requires UM/UIM coverage then, and because the other car may have no insurance. The article on uninsured motorist claims covers the general Insurance Code rules. TNC UM coverage is a specific layer on top of that general discussion.

What to collect

Save the trip receipt, the driver’s name as shown in the app, photographs, the police report number, and the names of any other insurers who call you. Do not delete the app history. Note whether you had accepted a ride, were waiting for a request, or had a passenger. That single fact changes the available limits by hundreds of thousands of dollars.

This page describes the insurance structure. It does not say which insurer must pay a particular crash, and it does not file a claim.

If more than one company calls you, ask each one which period it believes applies and which policy number it is handling. Write the answers down. A period 1 conversation and a period 3 conversation are not interchangeable, and a recorded statement given to the wrong desk can be quoted later as if you had described a different trip. Passengers should also keep the bank or card record of the ride charge. That charge is independent proof that a trip existed at a particular minute, which is often how period 3 is established when the app history is unclear. Other injured drivers should keep their own insurer informed, because a personal collision claim and a claim against the rideshare policy can run at the same time without being the same claim.

This is general information about California law, not legal advice. Deadlines and exceptions depend on the facts. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Find an attorney