Explainers / Injury

Slip and fall claims in California

A slip and fall is a premises-liability claim with a particular fact pattern. Someone slipped or tripped on property controlled by another person or business, and an injury followed. California does not pay people for falling. It asks whether the person in control of the property failed to use reasonable care and whether that failure caused the injury. The general duty is discussed in the premises-liability article. This page is about the proof that slip and trip cases actually turn on.

The condition

The condition might be a spilled liquid, a freshly mopped floor with no sign, a torn mat, a broken sidewalk slab, ice in a walk-in freezer, or a change in elevation that is hard to see. The plaintiff has to identify what caused the fall. “I just fell” is not enough if no one can say whether the floor was wet, uneven, or simply missed by a foot. Photographs taken before the area is mopped or coned off are the single most useful piece of evidence. If you are hurt and cannot take them, ask someone else. A picture the next day, after the store has cleaned the aisle, shows a clean aisle.

Video is the next most useful piece. Many businesses overwrite cameras within a few days. A short written request to preserve footage, sent while you still know the date and the camera location, is more effective than a request a month later. The request does not force the business to admit fault. It asks them not to destroy a recording.

Notice

A store is not automatically responsible for a spill that a customer dropped ten seconds earlier. The plaintiff generally must show that the business created the condition, knew about it, or should have known about it because it lasted long enough to be found by a reasonable inspection. That last theory is constructive notice. Evidence includes how large and obvious the spill was, whether it had tracks through it, employee inspection logs, and the video timeline. A business that inspects aisles on a schedule and can show the schedule was followed has a defense. A business with no inspections and a dried, dirty spill has a problem.

Employees who create the hazard are a different path. A mop bucket left in a path, or a leak from equipment the store maintains, does not require the same “how long did it sit there” proof, because the defendant created it. Identifying whether an employee was involved is one reason the incident report and witness names matter.

Outdoor falls add weather and ownership. Rain on an uncovered step is not always a breach of duty. A hidden change in the concrete, a broken handrail required by code, or a puddle from a neglected drain can be. Who owns the sidewalk, the city or the adjacent property owner, changes both the duty and the deadline. Cities often have ordinances that shift some sidewalk duties to the adjacent owner and still remain involved as a public entity. If the city might be responsible, the six-month government claim under Government Code section 911.2 has to be studied immediately.

Injuries that show up later

A wrist fracture is obvious. A back injury or a head injury may not be. Seeking medical care creates a record that connects the fall to the symptoms. A delay of weeks, with no treatment, is an argument the defense will make about causation. You do not need every specialist visit finished before you ask a question. You do need an honest timeline.

Comparative fault is routine in these cases. Walking while reading a phone, wearing shoes unsuited to a marked wet floor, or stepping over a cone can reduce the claim. It rarely erases the claim by itself under California’s pure comparative-fault rule. An open-and-obvious argument is similar: it matters, and it is not a magic dismissal in every case.

Lawsuits and insurance

The lawsuit deadline against a private business or owner is generally two years from the fall under Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1. The business’s liability insurer is who usually evaluates the claim before suit. An incident report filled out for the store is a statement. Read it. Do not write that you are fine if you have not been examined, and do not write a legal conclusion about fault.

Medical bills, wage loss, and pain are the usual damages. Pre-existing conditions do not bar a claim if the fall made them worse. They do require the records to separate what was already there from what changed. A firm will ask for those records if it considers the case. A directory listing is not that review.

Slip and fall cases are won and lost on minutes of video and on whether anyone should have found the hazard. This article tells you what those minutes are for. It does not say that a particular store was careless.

This is general information about California law, not legal advice. Deadlines and exceptions depend on the facts. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Find an attorney