Explainers / Consumer

California lemon law and the Song-Beverly Act

California’s lemon law for consumer goods is the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, Civil Code section 1790 and the sections that follow. For many new motor vehicles, the statute is the reason a buyer or lessee can ask a manufacturer to repurchase or replace a vehicle when a warranty defect is not fixed after a reasonable chance to repair it. The result is not automatic. The warranty, the defect, the repair history, and the kind of transaction all matter.

What the statute is trying to do

A warranty is a promise about the product. When a covered problem keeps coming back, the buyer has already given the warrantor a chance to make the product work. Song-Beverly sets rules for that situation instead of leaving every dispute to whatever the warranty booklet says. It applies to many consumer goods sold in California, not only cars. Vehicles get extra, more specific rules because a car that cannot be relied on affects safety, work, and daily life.

The vehicle rules people usually mean by “lemon law” are in Civil Code section 1793.2. For a new motor vehicle, if the manufacturer or its representative cannot conform the vehicle to the applicable express warranty after a reasonable number of attempts, the manufacturer must promptly replace the vehicle or make restitution, subject to the statute’s rules on mileage and use. “Promptly” and “reasonable” are legal words. They are measured against the repair record, not against a slogan.

What counts as a problem

The defect, called a nonconformity in the statute, has to be covered by the warranty and has to substantially impair the use, value, or safety of the vehicle to the buyer. A rattle that no one can find, a preference about how a seat feels, and a problem the warranty excludes are not the same case as a stall, a brake warning that returns, or a transmission that will not stay in gear. The buyer does not have to be a mechanic. The buyer does have to be able to describe what the vehicle does, when it does it, and what the dealer wrote down.

Keep every repair order. The useful lines are the date, the mileage, the complaint in the customer’s words, the technician’s finding, and the work performed. A visit that is written up as “could not duplicate” still belongs in the file if the problem returned. So do days the vehicle spent at the dealer waiting on a part. Those days are often how people show that the vehicle was out of service.

The Tanner presumption is not the whole law

Civil Code section 1793.22, often called the Tanner Consumer Protection Act, creates a rebuttable presumption in some cases. During the first 18 months or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first, the presumption can arise if the same nonconformity has been subject to repair four or more times, or two or more times if it is a serious safety defect, or if the vehicle has been out of service for repair of nonconformities for more than 30 calendar days. That presumption helps a buyer. It does not decide every case, and it is not a filing deadline. A vehicle outside that window can still be evaluated under the “reasonable number of attempts” standard in section 1793.2. A vehicle inside the window is not a lemon merely because someone counted visits without reading what was wrong.

Manufacturer-run repair programs and notice rules can also matter. Some warranties tell the owner to notify the manufacturer before a particular remedy is available. Missing a step in a booklet is not the same thing as losing every right under the statute, but it is a fact a reader should not ignore. The California Department of Consumer Affairs publishes information about the state’s lemon law processes. Those pages describe procedure. They do not decide a particular vehicle.

Used vehicles and leases

A used vehicle is not automatically outside the statute. Civil Code section 1795.5 addresses used consumer goods that are sold with an express warranty in California. When that section applies, implied warranties can attach for a stated period, and the goods can be treated in important ways like new goods for Song-Beverly purposes. A used car sold “as is,” with no express warranty, is a different transaction from a certified used car that comes with a manufacturer warranty that is still in effect. Civil Code section 1793.22 also addresses some leased vehicles and vehicles sold with a remaining manufacturer’s new-car warranty. The contract and the warranty booklet have to be read together. A salesperson’s sentence at the desk is not a substitute for those papers.

There is a separate cooling-off rule for many used-vehicle purchases and leases. Civil Code section 1784.43 requires a dealer, in covered sales and leases of a used vehicle priced at $50,000 or less, to provide a three-day right to cancel, with limits that include how far the vehicle is driven after delivery. That right is about canceling the deal. It is not the same claim as a Song-Beverly repurchase after months of unsuccessful repairs. Older materials still describe a paid two-day cancellation option under the Vehicle Code. The current statute to read for the cooling-off right is section 1784.43, and the dealer must give a disclosure that explains how to use it.

What a buyer can ask for, and what it costs to find out

If the statute’s repurchase or replacement duty is triggered, restitution generally includes the amount paid, with adjustments the statute allows, including an offset for use in many vehicle cases. A replacement is another vehicle, not a promise that the next car will be perfect. Incidental costs, such as towing or a rental in some situations, depend on the facts and the warranty. Civil Code section 1794 addresses a buyer’s remedies for a Song-Beverly violation, including damages and, when the buyer prevails, the costs and expenses the court finds were reasonably incurred, which can include attorney’s fees based on actual time. A fee statute is not a promise that a particular firm will charge nothing, and it is not a reason to skip reading a written fee agreement.

People sometimes ask whether a short repair count ends the question. It does not. The presumption is rebuttable, other repairs may involve a different defect, and the manufacturer can dispute whether the problem substantially impaired use, value, or safety. The practical starting point is still the paper: purchase or lease contract, warranty, every repair order, and messages with the dealer or manufacturer.

Deadlines

A Song-Beverly claim for breach of warranty is often treated as having a four-year period under Commercial Code section 2725, which is the statute of limitations for breach of a contract for sale. When that period starts can depend on when the breach occurred and on the repair history. Other consumer statutes, including the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, use different clocks and sometimes require a notice letter before a damages suit. A conversation with a firm is the place to ask which clock applies to a particular vehicle. This article cannot count the days.

The directory at Find a California Lawyer lists firms that say they handle lemon law. Choosing a name there, or reading this page, does not hire anyone and does not stop a deadline.

This is general information about California law, not legal advice. Deadlines and exceptions depend on the facts. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Find an attorney