Explainers / Injury
Uninsured and underinsured motorist claims in California
When the other driver has no insurance, or not enough, the injured person’s own uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is often the practical source of payment. California requires insurers to offer that coverage. It is not a second lawsuit against your own insurer in the ordinary sense, and it is not automatic money. The policy, the statute, and the proof of the other driver’s lack of coverage all have to line up.
What the statute requires
Insurance Code section 11580.2 requires automobile liability policies in California to provide uninsured motorist coverage, unless the insured rejects it in a signed writing that meets the statute. The coverage pays damages the insured is legally entitled to recover from the owner or operator of an uninsured motor vehicle because of bodily injury. Property damage to your own car is generally not what UM bodily-injury coverage pays. Collision coverage, if you bought it, is the usual source for the car itself.
The statute sets a minimum UM limit equal to the state’s financial-responsibility minimums, and it allows the insured to purchase higher limits up to the liability limits of the policy. Many people carry more than the minimum because California’s required liability limits are low relative to medical costs. The declarations page, not a memory of the sales call, shows the limit.
Underinsured motorist coverage addresses the driver who has some insurance, but not enough to cover the damages. Section 11580.2 treats an underinsured vehicle as one whose liability limits are less than the injured person’s UM limits. The injured person generally must first deal with the other driver’s insurer. UIM then covers the gap between the other driver’s payment and the UM limit, subject to the policy and the statute. It does not stack on top of the other driver’s payment to produce a windfall above the UM limit in the ordinary case. Offsets are a common dispute. Read the exhaustion language before assuming you can ignore the other policy.
Who is an uninsured motorist
An uninsured motor vehicle includes a vehicle with no liability insurance, a vehicle whose insurer denies coverage or becomes insolvent in the circumstances the statute describes, and a hit-and-run vehicle when the requirements of the statute are met. Hit-and-run claims have a specific reporting element. The statute generally requires that the accident be reported to the police within 24 hours and that the insured’s carrier be notified within 30 days, unless those requirements are excused. A reader who was hit by a driver who fled should not wait a month to mention it. Those short periods are independent of the two-year lawsuit clock.
A vehicle driven by someone excluded from the owner’s policy, or a vehicle used as a taxi or rideshare outside what the personal policy covers, can also function as uninsured from the victim’s point of view. The rideshare article describes the commercial coverage that may fill that gap when the app was on. If the commercial policy applies, the driver may not be “uninsured” at all. Sorting that fact comes before opening a UM claim.
How a UM claim is different from a third-party claim
In a claim against the other driver, you negotiate with that person’s insurer and you can sue that person in court. In a UM claim, you are making a claim on your own policy for the damages the uninsured driver would have owed. Many policies require arbitration of UM disputes rather than a jury trial. The arbitrator decides liability and damages under the same comparative-fault rules that would apply in court. Your own insurer is not your lawyer. It owes duties under the policy and under the implied covenant of good faith, and it also has a right to investigate. Those roles coexist. Be accurate. Do not treat the claim as a casual reimbursement.
Insurance Code section 11580.2 also limits stacking and sets credit for other recoveries, including workers’ compensation in some wording. A person hurt on the job by an uninsured driver may have both a compensation claim and a UM claim, with the compensation carrier asserting a right to part of the UM recovery. Ignoring the lien is how people spend money they later have to repay.
Notice and the lawsuit deadline
Policies require prompt notice of an accident. The statute ties some UM procedures to the underlying limitation period. A demand for arbitration often has to be made within a time related to Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1’s two years, and policies add their own contractual limits that courts sometimes enforce if they are conspicuous and lawful. Do not assume you can open a UM claim on the last day of the second year without having notified the insurer. Notify the insurer when you learn the other driver is uninsured or underinsured, in writing, and keep the letter.
A government vehicle can be “uninsured” in a practical sense because the public entity is not an ordinary liability carrier, but the six-month government claim is still required if you intend to pursue the entity. UM coverage does not excuse that presentation.
What to send, and what not to assume
Send the police report, the other driver’s information or the lack of it, medical bills as they exist, and your declarations page. Do not assume the limit is the minimum if you have not read the page. Do not assume a hit-and-run qualifies if it was never reported to the police. This article explains the coverage. It does not open a claim or state what a policy will pay.
This is general information about California law, not legal advice. Deadlines and exceptions depend on the facts. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship.